Airtag Pros and Cons [My Personal Experience]

In this guide, we will check out the pros and cons of Airtags based on my experience with them – both the good, the bad, and the (honestly, not too) ugly.

In general, even though there are a few annoying things about them, I still believe they are incredibly useful gadgets for not losing stuff.

Airtag prosAirtag cons
User experienceLimited compatibility
Precise trackingLimited reach
Offline trackingBattery life variability
Lost modeReliance on Bluetooth and network
Integration with Apple ecosystemInitial cost
Replaceable batteryPrivacy concerns
Compact and lightweightNeed for holders
Elegant design

Airtag pros

These are the main pros of Airtag.

User experience

airtag user experience

The user experience (UX) of the Airtag is exceptional, aligning perfectly with Apple’s reputation for delivering intuitive and seamless interactions.

From the moment I paired my Airtag with my iPhone using the Find My app, I was impressed by how effortlessly they integrated into my ecosystem. The setup process was a breeze, and attaching it to my essential items became a straightforward task.

The UX truly shines when it comes to locating items – a quick tap in the app reveals the precise location, and the proximity tracking is impressively accurate, guiding me seamlessly to my misplaced belongings.

Precise tracking

Airtags’ precise tracking capabilities have truly revolutionized the way I keep track of my belongings. Whether it’s my keys, wallet, or even my backpack, Airtags have consistently delivered pinpoint accuracy in locating these items within seconds. The reassurance that comes from knowing exactly where my essentials are at all times is a game-changer, saving me valuable time and reducing unnecessary stress.

What I find most remarkable is the seamless integration of Airtags with the Find My app. The moment I tap into the app to locate an item, the precision of the tracking is evident as it guides me, step by step, to the exact spot where the Airtag is located. This level of accuracy has turned finding misplaced items into a hassle-free endeavor, eliminating the frantic searches that used to consume my time. The peace of mind that comes from Airtags’ precise tracking is, without a doubt, one of the standout features that have solidified their place in my daily routine.

Airtag’s precise tracking has exceeded my expectations and has become an indispensable tool in my life. The convenience and efficiency it brings are unmatched, and I can confidently say that the days of frantically searching for lost items are a thing of the past. Airtags have undoubtedly earned their place as an invaluable addition to my collection of tech gadgets, and I can’t help but recommend them to anyone seeking a smarter and more organized way to keep track of their belongings.

Offline tracking

One of the standout features of Airtag that has truly impressed me is their ability to track items even when they’re offline. This functionality has proven to be a game-changer in situations where I’ve temporarily lost connectivity or misplaced an item in an area with weak signal. The fact that Airtag can utilize nearby Apple devices to update their location and then share that information with me once I’m back online showcases the level of thoughtfulness that Apple has put into enhancing the user experience. It’s a testament to Airtag’s reliability and practicality that goes beyond traditional tracking devices.

Whether I’m traveling, in a crowded place, or even just at home, I can trust that Airtag are diligently keeping tabs on my belongings, even when they’re not directly connected to my phone.

Lost mode

airtag lost mode

The “Lost Mode” feature offered by Airtags has proven to be a true lifesaver for me, and I can’t help but sing its praises. There’s an incredible sense of relief that comes from knowing that if I ever misplace an item with an Airtag attached, I can mark it as lost and receive notifications the moment it’s located. This proactive approach to handling lost items is a testament to Apple’s dedication to user experience. Being able to leverage the vast network of Apple devices to help locate my belongings is a feature I didn’t know I needed until I experienced it firsthand.

One instance that truly highlighted the power of the “Lost Mode” was when I misplaced my backpack while on a trip. I quickly marked it as lost using the Find My app, and within hours, I received a notification that my backpack had been detected in a nearby café.

Integration with Apple ecosystem

As someone who relies on various Apple devices, having Airtags effortlessly integrate with the Find My app and sync across my iPhone, iPad, and even my Mac has been a game-changer. The ability to locate my belongings using any of these devices adds a level of convenience that makes the tracking experience truly cohesive and intuitive.

What’s even more remarkable is the broader network that Airtags tap into. The vast community of Apple devices acting as anonymous Bluetooth beacons significantly enhances the chances of locating lost items quickly. The fact that an Apple device owned by someone else could inadvertently help me locate a misplaced item underscores the power of the ecosystem’s collaborative nature. The integration extends beyond devices too – Airtag integrate seamlessly with Siri, allowing me to ask for the location of specific items hands-free.

Replaceable battery

Being able to easily replace the battery myself has not only saved me the hassle of constantly buying new devices but has also minimized electronic waste. I appreciate the fact that I can extend the lifespan of my Airtag without contributing to the growing issue of disposable technology.

With a simple twist, I can access the battery compartment and replace it with minimal effort.

Compact and lightweight

airtag compactness and light weight

The compactness and lightweight design of Airtag have been useful and convenient in my daily life. The small form factor ensures that attaching an Airtag to any item doesn’t add bulk or inconvenience. Whether it’s my keys, my wallet, or even my pet’s collar, the Airtag’s unobtrusive size makes it effortless to incorporate into my belongings without compromising their usability.

The lightweight nature of Airtag is especially valuable when I’m on the go. I’ve often forgotten that I’ve attached an Airtag to an item due to its minimal weight, which is a testament to how seamlessly it blends into my routine. The last thing I want is to add unnecessary weight to items I carry around, and Airtag’s lightweight design ensures that this concern is never an issue.

Elegant design

airtag design

Man, let me tell you, the Airtag’s elegant design is the real deal. These sleek little discs are like the James Bond of tracking devices – they’re so understated yet incredibly effective. I remember attaching one to my laptop bag, and it just seamlessly blended in, like it was meant to be there all along. No bulky attachments, no flashy colors – just this discreet tracker that does its job without making a big fuss.

And here’s the kicker – that elegant design isn’t just for show. I’ve had moments where I’ve slipped an Airtag into my wallet and realized how much more organized my life became. Instead of rummaging through my bag at the coffee shop counter, I could just discreetly use the Find My app to pinpoint my wallet’s location, thanks to that elegant little disc. It’s like having this secret weapon that keeps me on top of things without drawing any attention. Honestly, I can’t help but appreciate how Airtags’ design is all about efficiency and subtlety – making life easier without making a scene.

Airtag cons

These are the cons of Airtag.

Limited compatibility

While I’ve enjoyed the benefits of Airtags in my own Apple ecosystem, I can’t help but feel a tinge of disappointment when considering their limited compatibility. The exclusive integration with Apple devices is undoubtedly a downside that restricts the broader potential of Airtags. Friends and family who rely on Android devices are unable to use AirTags and experience the convenience and efficiency that these trackers offer, creating a barrier that prevents them from benefiting from this innovative technology.

This limited compatibility not only restricts the reach of the Airtag but also misses an opportunity to broaden their impact. The technology itself is impressive, and I can’t help but think about the countless individuals who could benefit from it if they were more universally accessible. It’s frustrating to see such a promising product be confined to a specific ecosystem when its capabilities could be shared with a wider audience.

Limited reach

airtag limited reach

While the integration with the Apple ecosystem is seamless and impressive, Airtags’ reliance on Bluetooth technology means that their effective range is quite limited compared to other tracking solutions. This limitation has occasionally led to situations where I couldn’t track an item that was located just beyond the Bluetooth range, leaving me without the accurate location I had come to rely on.

The fact that Airtags require proximity to an Apple device to update their location is both a strength and a weakness. While it’s great that Airtags can tap into a vast network of devices for tracking, the reality is that this network’s reach is still constrained. As someone who values reliable and comprehensive tracking, I’ve encountered instances where the limitations of Bluetooth tracking have hindered my ability to locate items efficiently.

You should also keep in mind that in general, AirTags don’t track without a phone.

Battery life variability

The inconsistency in Airtag battery life has been a bit of a letdown for me.

While the replaceable battery is a great feature in theory, the actual battery life has varied quite a bit for different Airtags I’ve used.

For instance, one Airtag seemed to last a solid eight months before needing a battery change, while another required a replacement after just four months. This unpredictability has thrown off my expectations and made it challenging to rely on Airtags for consistent tracking without the worry of sudden battery depletion.

In another instance, I had attached an Airtag to a suitcase for a trip, confident that it would last the duration. To my dismay, the Airtag’s battery gave out halfway through my journey, leaving me without the tracking ability I had come to depend on.

Similarly, I’ve experienced situations where I wanted to locate an item, only to find that the Airtag’s battery had died at a crucial moment. This variability has highlighted the need for more consistent battery performance, as relying on Airtags for essential tracking can sometimes be a bit of a gamble.

Reliance on the Internet and Bluetooth

The heavy reliance of Airtags on both the Internet and Bluetooth has been a bit of a downer for me. There have been times when I’ve needed to track an item while out and about, only to find that I’m in an area with weak Bluetooth signal or no internet connectivity.

One incident that stands out was when I misplaced my keys during a camping trip, and I realized I couldn’t locate them with my Airtag because we were in an area with no cell service. It’s frustrating that Airtags’ effectiveness is heavily dependent on both these factors, as it limits their reliability in situations where you need them the most.

Initial cost

The price of an Apirtag is definitely not a favorite property of mine.

While they offer great tracking features, the cost can add up, especially when I wanted to attach Airtags to multiple items like my keys, wallet, and backpack.

When I wanted to equip my luggage and a few essential items with Airtags before a trip, I found myself hesitant due to the total expense adding to my travel budget. This pricing consideration has made me think twice about fully outfitting my belongings with Airtags, impacting my ability to enjoy their convenience across all aspects of my life.

Privacy concerns

The whole deal with Airtag privacy has left me scratching my head a bit.

Don’t get me wrong, I love the convenience.

But the thought of these little trackers potentially being used to track people without their consent just doesn’t sit right with me.

I mean, I get that Apple added the notification thing if an unknown Airtag is hanging around, but what about those situations where someone isn’t nearby to get the alert? I’ve had moments where I wondered if someone could sneak an Airtag onto my stuff without me knowing, and it’s just weird thinking about that level of potential intrusion.

And don’t even get me started on how Airtags could potentially be misused.

I’ve seen discussions online about people being worried that Airtags could be used for stalking or tracking without someone’s knowledge, and that’s a serious concern. Even though I trust Apple’s focus on privacy, the fact remains that Airtags could still be manipulated in ways that invade personal space.

I get that Apple’s trying to find a balance, but the privacy thing is definitely a gray area that’s made me question whether the convenience of Airtags is worth potentially compromising my own privacy or that of others.

Need for holders

airtag holder

Here’s one finall small thing that’s kind of bothering me about the Airtag – the whole need for holders.

I mean, the fact that I need to buy a separate holder or attachment to hook up the Airtag to my stuff kind of baffles me. It’s like, okay, I’ve already shelled out for the Airtag itself, and now I need to buy more accessories just to make it work the way I want it to? I get it, they’re going for customization and all, but shouldn’t the basic package cover the essentials?

And it’s not just about the cost – it’s the hassle. I’ve had moments where I wanted to attach an Airtag to something small like my earbuds or my glasses, and realizing I need to find a suitable holder that won’t get in the way is just a bit of an annoyance. It’s like this extra step that kind of takes away from the seamless tracking experience that Airtags promise. I appreciate the idea of choice, but there are times when I wish Airtags could just attach neatly without me having to hunt down the perfect accessory. It’s one of those things that make me wonder if the convenience of Airtags is worth the extra bit of effort.

I usually keep Airtags in my wallet when I can, and the unexpected part about this is that they can even fit in a minimalist wallet.

Are Airtags worth it?

Even though Airtags have several downsides, I’ve found them to be incredibly useful in my day-to-day life. In fact, I might even say that I would find life to be impossible without them. So, despite the few disadvantages, I still recommend them as a great way to keep track of your items.

Want to get cool tech and gadget tips, exclusive discounts and promotions, and unseen tech hacks? Join TechSecrets.

Matt standing next to his Xiaomi M365 Pro electric scooter and holding an electric scooter helmet
I love all things tech, so I decided to make a blog about technology, electronics, gadgets, accessories, and all the various items we use every day that make our lives easier. I like doing a lot of research on various models and brands, looking for great value and performance, both through data and experience.